4.4 The article “One Hundred Years of Race and Crime” by Paul Butler explores how racial justice and criminal justice have evolved in the U.S. over the

4.4

The article “One Hundred Years of Race and Crime” by Paul Butler explores how racial justice and criminal justice have evolved in the U.S. over the past century. Butler compares the racial issues in criminal law from 1910 to those of 2010, showing that although there has been symbolic racial progress (like having Black prosecutors or a Black president), material inequalities like mass incarceration and racial disparities in sentencing have worsened.

He contrasts two main views:

1. The “New Jim Crow” view: Mass incarceration is the modern version of racial oppression, replacing slavery and Jim Crow laws.

2. The “celebratory tradition” view: Criminal justice has made progress by protecting Black victims more and including more Black professionals in the system.

Butler argues that while the law has improved symbolically (e.g., more rights and protections), it hasn’t materially improved outcomes for Black Americans in the justice system, especially due to drug laws and racialized enforcement. He calls for more direct, race-conscious reforms to fix these deep-rooted problems.(This a Summary of the Article)

After reading the Paul Butler article, think about whether it’s possible for the criminal legal system to make progress on racial justice and still cause harm at the same time. Can both be true?

To help you answer, be sure to:

  1. Briefly explain the two perspectives Butler discusses: the New Jim Crow view and the Celebratory tradition. What are the main ideas behind each one? How are they similar or different?
  2. Decide whether these two views can go together. Can they both be right in some way? Or are they too different to be reconciled? Explain your reasoning.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

You will select a topic related to a certain issue the United States is currently dealing with that relates in some way to fraud and financial crime.

You will select a topic related to a certain issue the United States is currently dealing with that relates in some way to fraud and financial crime. MONEY LAUNDERING issues in the United States IS THE TOPIC   The presentation should focus on the current controversies surrounding the specific topic issue you selected.  Let’s say you find

Submit a formal research paper (10-15 pages), which is worth 45% of your course grade. Your paper needs to analyze the jury selection process and its

Submit a formal research paper (10-15 pages), which is worth 45% of your course grade. Your paper needs to analyze the jury selection process and its relationship to both: (a) Constitutional law, and (b) an allied field (e.g., education, history, law enforcement, public administration, public policy, psychology, sociology, technology, etc.).   For this assignment,

The Research Paper will be 19% of the course grade and consist of 14-20 double spaced pages (excluding title page and reference page). The research will

The Research Paper will be 19% of the course grade and consist of 14-20 double spaced pages (excluding title page and reference page). The research will address one of the following five topics:1. Terrorism and Organized Crime: Similarities and Differences (Connected to Course Learning Objective #4, i.e., Report on how terrorism differs from organized

For this discussion, please address the following: How do redemption scripts, as conceptualized in desistance theory, shape an individual’s narrative of

For this discussion, please address the following: How do redemption scripts, as conceptualized in desistance theory, shape an individual’s narrative of personal transformation and influence the likelihood of successful reintegration into society? What role do these scripts play in fostering a sense of agency and empowerment for those seeking to