4.4 The article “One Hundred Years of Race and Crime” by Paul Butler explores how racial justice and criminal justice have evolved in the U.S. over the

4.4

The article “One Hundred Years of Race and Crime” by Paul Butler explores how racial justice and criminal justice have evolved in the U.S. over the past century. Butler compares the racial issues in criminal law from 1910 to those of 2010, showing that although there has been symbolic racial progress (like having Black prosecutors or a Black president), material inequalities like mass incarceration and racial disparities in sentencing have worsened.

He contrasts two main views:

1. The “New Jim Crow” view: Mass incarceration is the modern version of racial oppression, replacing slavery and Jim Crow laws.

2. The “celebratory tradition” view: Criminal justice has made progress by protecting Black victims more and including more Black professionals in the system.

Butler argues that while the law has improved symbolically (e.g., more rights and protections), it hasn’t materially improved outcomes for Black Americans in the justice system, especially due to drug laws and racialized enforcement. He calls for more direct, race-conscious reforms to fix these deep-rooted problems.(This a Summary of the Article)

After reading the Paul Butler article, think about whether it’s possible for the criminal legal system to make progress on racial justice and still cause harm at the same time. Can both be true?

To help you answer, be sure to:

  1. Briefly explain the two perspectives Butler discusses: the New Jim Crow view and the Celebratory tradition. What are the main ideas behind each one? How are they similar or different?
  2. Decide whether these two views can go together. Can they both be right in some way? Or are they too different to be reconciled? Explain your reasoning.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

In this assignment, you will identify issues confronting modern law enforcement, corrections, and the court system; reflect on policies that currently

In this assignment, you will identify issues confronting modern law enforcement, corrections, and the court system; reflect on policies that currently impact those components of the criminal justice system; and point out problems that exist in today’s criminal justice system.  Consider situations in the criminal justice system that have developed

Write 400–600 words that respond to the following questions with your thoughts, ideas, and comments. This will be the foundation for future discussions by

Write 400–600 words that respond to the following questions with your thoughts, ideas, and comments. This will be the foundation for future discussions by your classmates. Be substantive and clear, and use examples to reinforce your ideas. Examine the Transportation Security Administration’s (TSA) policy development, interaction with the public, and

Report on “Analysing Surrogacy Case of Nepal from Economic School of Jurisprudence” Report on “Analysing Surrogacy Case of Nepal from Economic School of

Report on “Analysing Surrogacy Case of Nepal from Economic School of Jurisprudence” Report on “Analysing Surrogacy Case of Nepal from Economic School of Jurisprudence” Apply the principles of the Economic School of Jurisprudence, which addresses how laws and regulations of a legal system impact economic efficiency, resource allocation, and incentives,

Description Deliverable Length: 3 pages For this assignment, complete the following: Develop a problem statement and background paper for an issue that

Description Deliverable Length: 3 pages For this assignment, complete the following: Develop a problem statement and background paper for an issue that affects multiple agencies or jurisdictions in the homeland security (HLS) enterprise. The issue should be consistent with the topics evaluated in the Quadrennial Homeland Security Review (QHSR). Consider policy,