Based on your individual case analysis, please answer the following questions
in your own words:
1. Identifies Dilemma.
2. Considers Stakeholders.
3. Analyzes Alternatives and Consequences.
4. Identifies Appropriate Ethical Frameworks for Evaluating Alternatives.
5. Choose an Action.
Notes: Please write each paragraph in complete sentences for each criterion,
using your own words to clearly and effectively convey the ideas. Each
paragraph should begin with a strong topic sentence and include supporting
details. Avoid using sentence fragments. This assignment will adhere to the
late submission policy, as well as the Turnitin and AI Generative Tools Policy
outlined in the syllabus.
Below is the rubric that has been created by the LFCoB.
Unacceptabl
e
Acceptable Exemplary
Identifies
Dilemma
States a
specific
ethical
dilemma
exists, but
fails to
discuss
potential
decisions
Identifies the
ethical
dilemma,
including
pertinent
facts, and
states what
course of
action must
be
decided
Describes the ethical
dilemma in detail having
gathered all available
pertinent facts. Identifies
and prioritizes key
decisions to be made.
Considers
Stakeholders
Fails to
identify who
should be
involved in the
decision-maki
ng process
Determines
who should
be involved in
the decision
making
process and
accurately
identifies
these key
Identifies and prioritizes
the perspectives of all
relevant stakeholders.
stakeholders’
perspectives.
Analyzes
Alternatives
and
Consequences
Basic
appraisal of
the relevant
facts and
assumptions
Identifies at
least two
alternatives
and evaluates
their
consequence
s
effectively.
Identifies multiple
alternatives and
evaluates their
consequences
effectively and
insightfully.
Identifies
Appropriate
Ethical
Frameworks
for Evaluating
Alternatives
Does not
apply any
theoretical
ethical
framework in
evaluating
alternatives or
applies one or
more
approaches
inappropriatel
y
Identifies and
applies at
least one
appropriate
theoretical
ethical
framework for
evaluating
alternatives.
Identifies and applies
multiple, appropriate
theoretical ethical
frameworks for
evaluating alternatives
and explains how these
inform decision making.
Chooses an
Action
Does not
identify and/or
explain
appropriate
decision for a
course of
action from
among
alternatives
actions.
Formulates a
decision and
articulates a
plan for
implementing
it.
Formulates a decision
and articulates a plan for
implementing it that
evidences
understanding of the
motives and
consequences of action.
==================================
Students are required to write in organized paragraphs with complete
sentences. Do not use bullet points or direct quotes. Please do not upload
pdf/page files. Turnitin and AI Generative Tools on the syllabus will be applied.
Minimum Word Requirements: Students are required to write at least 300 words.
This does not count the assignment questions. I require minimum word counts
to give students an idea of how much work is expected. Otherwise, students may do
much less than they need to do in order to develop their critical and analytical
thinking skills.
